Adverb EVER to make the sentence clearer?

I have just read this article:

http://literalminded.wordpress.com/2014/07/08/open-conditionals-with-the-past-perfect/

I admit that it is quite tricky for an ESL as I am, nonetheless I caught sight of this sentence:

But the plane dispatched to the position of another smaller blip found nothing. If there had been a lifeboat, it had sunk.

I was wondering whether the adverb ever could have made the meaning of the sentence above clearer:

But the plane dispatched to the position of another smaller blip found nothing. If there had EVER been a lifeboat, it had sunk.

Answer

I think “ever” here is redundant.
It is technically OK, but since the described event had a relative start and end time in the past, you don’t need it.

Ever is more often used to refer to any/all time, as in:

Have you ever gone to New York?
They lived happily ever after.

Attribution
Source : Link , Question Author : jeysmith , Answer Author : user3169

Leave a Comment