eligibility criterion for an -ing form to serve as a deverbal adjective

a dog which is barking can be rephrased as a barking dog; I am wondering whether a patient who is coughing can be rephrased as a coughing patient?

similarly, can we rephrase something (such as a dog, a train, etc.) which is running as a running dog/ train, etc.?

the -ing form of some verbs can serve as a deverbal adjective, while that of others cannot. I am wondering what the eligibility criterion should be for an -ing form to function as a deverbal adjective so as to serve as a premodifier for a noun?

Answer

a barking dog / a coughing patient / a sleeping child

I’ve added the last example as it belongs in the same category as the other two.

I would say that the ing forms here are verb phrases, not adjectives. Even if they were adjectives, they would not be deverbal ones, but adjectives formed by conversion from verbs.

These attributive modifiers are best analysed as verb phrases, not adjectives, for a number of reasons:

They can’t be modified by “very”.

They can’t occur as complement to complex-intransitive verbs like “become” or “seem” (we can’t say *”It seemed/became quite barking” or *”He seemed/became quite coughing/ sleeping”).

They can’t occur as complement to complex-transitive verbs like “find” (we can’t say *”I found it quite barking” or *”I found him quite coughing/sleeping”).

The range of expressions that can occur as pre-head modifier to a noun is very large and varied: we don’t want to call them all adjectives. “Barking”, “coughing” and “sleeping” don’t have the properties of indisputable adjectives and hence can’t belong in that class.

Attribution
Source : Link , Question Author : Lynnyo , Answer Author : BillJ

Leave a Comment