Quote from the Pirates of Carribean

Here’s the scene. Jack and Angelica are in the captain’s quarters on Black Beard’s ship. They’re both looking at a shelf full of bottles that have ships inside them. One of them contains Jack’s ship named Black Pearl

Jack asks “Why is the Black Pearl in a bottle?”

Why does he say a bottle? It’s quite clear for both of them which specific bottle the ship is in because they’re looking at it when asks the question.

Answer

He isn’t asking why it is in that specific bottle. He’s asking why it is in a bottle at all.

Attribution
Source : Link , Question Author : Dunno , Answer Author : Kreiri

Leave a Comment